There’s something satisfying about playing pickleball and hearing the sound of paddle contacting ball, the distinct pop echoing off every visible vertical surface. 

But not everyone is so thrilled with the sounds of the United States’ fastest-growing sport.

Some Lake Junaluska property owners in recent months have made known their frustrations with what they describe as noise so loud and frequent it has created mental-health concerns. Ruth and Ted Singletary have led that charge. Given the pickleball courts’ popularity with folks from all over Haywood County and beyond, the Singletarys and their cadre of allies are outnumbered. But they aren’t backing down. While it may seem like the storyline from an episode of Parks and Recreation or Curb Your Enthusiasm, both sides are serious and firm on their positions.

The Singletarys first bought a home at Lake Junaluska, just over a hundred feet from where the courts now sit, in 1996. They bought the neighboring property in May 2025. The couple depends on both properties, which they operate as inns, for part of their income. They said that since 2021, they have spent most of their time living at the lake, but that now they’re second-guessing that decision.

“We don’t have a beef with the lake. We love the lake. We love the people,” Ruth said. “It’s just, we cannot survive like this anymore.”

But the pickleball’s popularity has created what feels like an unstoppable force the Singletarys must meet. Among fervent fans of the game are Lake Junaluska residents Denise and Steve Brooker. Denise, a lifelong tennis player, recently won a silver medal playing pickleball at the North Carolina Senior Games.

“We’re trying to come up with mitigation, compromises,” she said. “We don’t want it to shut down.” 

At the root of the argument is a utilitarian question: Are the enjoyment and health benefits hundreds receive from the courts so great that they can come at the expense of residents who claim they can’t even find serenity inside their own homes? As neither side wants to budge, it may be a question that can be answered only by Lake Junaluska’s leadership, or, as has been the case around the country, civil court.

A growing discontent

Given its almost cult-like following, many picklers can recite the game’s history. It was invented in 1965 by a congressman in Washington state. The niche sport had a modest following for decades. In November 2009, the first USA Pickleball Association National Tournament was held, but it wouldn’t be until a decade later that it would really catch on. When the coronavirus pandemic sent everyone into a social-distancing frenzy, the sport emerged as a new pastime. Courts can be set up just about anywhere, equipment is cheap, and the game is beloved by many for the social aspect, something many sought during COVID lockdowns.

Although the sport’s popularity appears to be leveling off, there are still enough picklers to create issues in cities from Mobile, Alabama, to San Jose, California. A website, pickleballnoiserelief.com, has galvanized the growing contingent of upset property owners looking for answers. There have even been lawsuits. Florida attorney Keith Grumer has helped numerous property owners win in court against their homeowners associations or municipal governments.

Pickleball has become a popular attraction at Lake Junaluska. Credit: Kyle Perrotti photo

More locally, the issue at Lake Junaluska caught the public’s eye through a letter to the editor in The Mountaineer that claimed the noise was creating mental health issues such as “anxiety, PTSD-like symptoms, and in extreme cases, suicidal thoughts,” although there was no elaboration. Those claims are based on a 2025 survey by Katleen Romito of Quiet Communities, which concluded that three of four people living within 1,000 feet of courts hear pickleball noises inside their homes, and half reported they’d been “harassed” by players. The survey report noted that the nuisance has grown to the point that there have been an estimated 200 legal claims nationwide.

“Kathleen Romero (sic), an Audiologist with over 14 years of experience, says that pickleball noise is four times louder than tennis,” the letter to the editor reads. “This is due to the sharp ‘pop’ that pickleballs produce, rather than the softer ‘ping’ that comes from tennis balls. Additionally, Kathleen reports that some residents can be exposed to 30,000-40,000 pops per day, without any relief or break from the noise.”

Alan Lang, a retired psychology researcher with vast experience editing and reviewing scholarly articles — and who is also an avid Lake Junaluska pickler — said the survey, which wasn’t peer-reviewed, doesn’t stand up to scrutiny. The way it has been used in arguments against the pickleball courts at Lake Junaluska has been misleading, he argues, adding that the method used was “purposeful sampling,” which means Romito was essentially seeking confirmation bias by recruiting advocates from neighborhoods who already had concerns about pickleball noise. Lang also criticized the loose claim that exposure to loud noises can cause PTSD; PTSD — per its name — requires trauma.

“They’re not evaluating rigorously what the methods are,” Lang told The Smoky Mountain News.

The Junaluska pickleball problem: A brief history

According to a timeline provided by Lake Junaluska Community Council (JACC) Chair David Hanson, residents at the lake in 2019 requested to play pickleball on two existing tennis courts in the recreation area. In 2021, play began on those two courts.

Haywood County in 2023 used a $290,000 American Rescue Plan grant to fund the construction of new courts. County Manager Bryant Morehead said administrators investigated potentially building the courts elsewhere, such as Allens Creek Park in Waynesville, but that area flooded during Helene and the county doesn’t own the property, so it was ruled out.

“Lake Junaluska is more central to the county,” Morehead said. “We were trying to be strategic in where we put it, and that was convenient for people.”

The county and the lake in 2024 signed a memorandum of understanding to construct six pickleball courts while also expanding and renovating existing restroom facilities.

Per the MOU, Lake Junaluska would manage the construction and receive up to $290,000 in reimbursement. The MOU further stipulates that the lake must make the facilities available to the county recreation department and tourism development authority for tournaments up to 10 times per year. Perhaps most noteworthy, it states that the courts “will be open to the public.” Morehead said that language reflects how the county has worked with Junaluska in the past to open its facilities for the good of all.

Court construction began in September 2024. After Hurricane Helene delayed the project slightly, it was completed in January 2025.

Ted Singletary said that up to about 2023, the courts weren’t too busy, but once more people started playing and the noise picked up earlier this year, he and some neighbors began to wonder why no one asked them their thoughts ahead of the new courts’ construction.

According to Hanson’s timeline, on April 24 of this year, the first pickleball noise complaint was received by the Lake Junaluska Assembly. In early September, the Singletarys circulated a petition they told SMN garnered signatures from over 40 households. The petition requested implementation of “physical sound barriers,” restriction of court access from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m., setting “current or future” courts back at least 500 feet from any homes, and requiring quiet equipment.

During a meeting on Sept. 8 of this year, Ruth Singletary voiced her concerns to the JACC, which basically operates like a municipal board, and asked what, if any, due diligence was done prior to the construction of the courts that may have considered the impact noise would have on nearby residents and guests, a sentiment other people during the public comment period echoed.

“ We find we greatly underestimated the level of disruptive noise emitted during gameplay,” said resident Grace Gattis.  

Last week’s meeting at Lake Junaluska brought out over 100 people. Credit: Kyle Perrotti photo

 Lake Junaluska Executive Director Ken Howell responded by first noting that the public had ample chance to weigh in before the MOU was signed. However, he also acknowledged that he and other leaders didn’t expect that people would take issue with the noise and said work to find solutions had already begun.

Lake Junaluska property owners established a committee made up of both avid pickleball players and those who are bothered by the noise — including the Singletarys and the Brookers — with Howell acting as a sort of mediator, tasked with determining potential solutions. It first met Oct. 6 and decided that initial actions should include establishing specific “play hours,” encourage the use of “quieter” equipment, and researching and implementing noise mitigation. The group concluded that play should begin no earlier than 8 a.m. Monday through Saturday and 10 a.m. on Sunday — times arrived at through a compromise.

A report on that committee meeting was presented at a JACC meeting the following week, where Ruth Singletary read a statement from “impacted homeowners.” The letter recommended closing pickleball courts entirely until “effective sound mitigation measures” could be implemented.

“Residents have been raising concerns for months, yet the noise continues unabated,” the letter read. “The ongoing disruption to our homes, businesses, quality of life, and well-being cannot simply be deferred while additional meetings are held. We were particularly disappointed that, after a two-hour committee meeting devoted to this issue, no meaningful restrictions on hours of play could be established. Moreover, existing expectations regarding start times are not being observed in practice.”

Following the statement, someone (it isn’t clear who by the meeting minutes) said it sounded like Singletary was threatening a lawsuit.

“We’re not threatening anything,” Singletary replied.

The committee met again Nov. 5 with the intention of addressing hours of play, quiet equipment, and a sound study update. The day before that meeting, Denise and Steve Brooker wrote a letter to fellow committee members; saying they “perceived [the impacted homeowners’ letter] as not very compromising.” 

“To say we must use ‘quiet equipment’ or ‘go somewhere else’ to play is not objective and is unrealistic,” it reads.  

The letter opined on nuisance laws, under which the Assembly could potentially be sued by those who feel their lives have been affected by the noise, concluding that “the abandonment of a valuable public facility is not in the ‘Overall Public Interest.’” 

At the Nov. 5 meeting, the hours of play were set to 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. Monday through Saturday with and 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. Sunday. The minutes from that meeting also noted that Lake Junaluska security has increased patrols to communicate to players the new hours and that the Assembly is researching automated access gates. 

While there was discussion about both reducing the number of courts where pickleball could be played and restricting play during the day (i.e., noon to 3 p.m.), there was no consensus on either matter.

The minutes also indicate that “quiet equipment” had been ordered and that signage encouraging the use of such equipment would be posted. A committee member issued a request for proposals and qualifications for a sound study to acoustic engineering firms and received proposals from four “experienced companies” with “most indicating a 4-to-5 week turnaround.” According to the minutes, Zoom calls were scheduled with those firms, but it isn’t clear whether those calls have happened.

Looking forward

At a Nov. 10 meeting of the JACC, picklers turned out en masse, some sporting well-worn sneakers, sweatbands, and thigh-high shorts as though they walked straight from the court to the meeting. Over a dozen people spoke, and only one seemed to be in favor of restrictions on play. Hanson began the comment period by encouraging speakers to offer not only their opinions but also potential solutions.

“Be civil. Be respectful. We’re all friends here, right?” he said.

The tenor of the meeting was overwhelmingly positive, seemingly to the surprise of JACC members, an easy achievement considering few, if any, who have lodged complaints about the noise were present. Many who commented were older folks who find joy in the social aspect of the game and all the benefits that come with regular exercise. One commenter asked picklers in the audience to raise their hands. It was hard to scan the crowd and find someone with their hand down. One commenter said he and his spouse moved to the area in part because of Lake Junaluska’s pickleball courts. Two military veterans said the game has helped their mental health. Some use the courts to practice for competitive tournaments.

While most who spoke were older, not all were gray-haired retirees. Tuscola High School Senior Madi Evans is the leader of her school’s pickleball club. While there are courts in Canton, she joked that Tuscola students want to steer clear of Pisgah Black Bear territory. Evans views the courts as a way to bring the community together; it’s a place where teenagers and older folks can develop bonds across generational lines.

“It’s built those bridges,” Evans said.

What is clear between SMN’s conversation with the Singletarys and comments at the Nov. 10 meeting is that the compromises at this point don’t seem to set well with either group.

Pickler Rick Moser makes an impassioned plea to let play go on at Lake Junaluska’s pickleball courts. Credit: Kyle Perrotti photo

First is restricting playing time. In the sea of retirees at last week’s JACC meeting sat a few working people who enjoy playing early enough in the morning or late enough in the evening that it doesn’t interfere with their jobs. One was Jeanette White, an engineer who said it’s difficult to get court time in with the current restrictions. She wasn’t in favor of reducing hours people could play, but she was in favor of sound-mitigation efforts like the installation of curtains or foliage to mitigate the noise.

While equipment that dampens the sound of each strike is going to be provided by the Assembly, there were several present at the Nov. 10 meeting who would not want to see their use made mandatory since tournament play requires use of normal equipment. To practice for competition with gear that differs from tournament equipment doesn’t suit their needs. In August of this year, public courts in Mashpee, Massachusetts, began requiring the use of quiet equipment. However, in a piece from NBC News Boston, a “pickleball noise expert” says a quieter ball doesn’t fix the problem. At the same time, players complained that the quiet balls are more expensive and don’t come off the paddle the same way.

“It’s like a sponge. It’s just, it’s garbage,” one player said, according to reporting from CBS News Boston.

Another option would be offering money to the Singletarys and others to install new windows that better insulate them from the noise. However, the couple said that doesn’t work well enough for them, as part of the appeal of lakeside living is sitting on their porch drinking a cup of coffee in the morning or a glass of wine in the evening, or even just getting out and doing yardwork.

When she spoke in September, Ruth Singletary said she was also worried about how the noise from the pickleball courts could impact a future sale of the property, should they wish to sell. Council Member Suzanne Crites brought this up during the Nov. 10 meeting. Although everyone who’d initially signed up to comment had spoken at that point, Jazmin Lopez, a local real estate agent asked to speak to that matter, and Hanson obliged. Lopez opined that based on her professional experience, someone wouldn’t have trouble selling property near the courts due to their desirability due to the proximity of the lake.

“I’m not saying they should have to sell. Nobody should have to sell their home because they’re being disturbed by noise. That is very unfair,” she said. “But as far as their property value, I think that’s a tough argument to make because it’s a high-value property.”

It’s hard to tell how the pickleball dispute will come to a resolution or even if it’s headed toward litigation. For now, both sides seem cemented in their positions, and the Singletarys are unwilling to back down, even against overwhelming opposition.

“The pickle ball people say, ‘Well, we have the numbers. We have hundreds of people that love pickleball, and it’s just a few disgruntled homeowners,’” Ruth Singletary said. “Well, this is not a numbers game. This is messing with our lives.”