Stephen Yerka, a preservation specialist at the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians’ (EBCI) Tribal Historic Preservation Office (THPO), receives 20 to 30 emails daily requesting consultation for governmental infrastructure projects. It’s par for the course, he explained, when the THPO oversees 140,000 square miles of non-tribal land that is traditional Cherokee territory across eight states and interacts with at least 90 federal agencies regularly.
Yerka’s responsibilities are outlined in the National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA), a framework that requires all undertakings funded or initiated by federal departments to consult with communities, governments, and historical offices and ensure these projects do not interfere with cultural or sacred places. THPOs were established after federally recognized tribal nations were incorporated into the act in 1992, and a core priority of EBCI’s office is to safeguard ancestral burial sites.
Attacks against Section 106 have persisted since the start of the second Trump presidency. Earlier this year, the Trump-appointed Advisory Council on Historic Preservation proposed a Section 106 rewrite that would limit consultation requirements. But the most pressing threat, preservation advocates say, is the Bipartisan Affordability and Jobs Act, or BAAJA, introduced in September and authored by both Democratic and Republican senators. In many cases, said Yerka during an Eastern Band of Cherokee THPO webinar on Nov. 7, the legislation would “really remove any of that responsibility from the agency” to consult with tribes about projects on traditional territory.
EBCI Lead Archaeologist Beau Carroll added that while tribal advocates knew this bill would surface at some point, they were taken aback by how quickly it was discussed.
On Nov. 9, BAAJA received 73 votes, 13 more than needed to pass Senate cloture. Proponents claim that amid skyrocketing costs of living and the danger of climate catastrophe, BAAJA incentivizes green energy while streamlining infrastructure projects serving Americans.
Despite its bipartisan popularity, environmental and tribal organizations have sounded the alarm. Conservationists point out that the bill would expedite permits by decreasing regulatory requirements for big oil and data centers. Tribal organizations are similarly concerned about the future — and they’re increasingly worried about losing ties to the past.
Carroll emphasized that NHPA — and tribal inclusion within it — wasn’t a product of U.S. government generosity but rather persistent tribal demands. He added that it doesn’t mean tribes have veto power over federal projects.
According to Yerka, the process is still imperfect: consultation is often delegated to new applicants who have no idea what it entails.
“I receive emails that are addressed to our principal chief that say, ‘Hey, chief, please concur with this project.’ In no way would they ever send an email like that to the president of the United States, but they’ll do it to our principal chief,” he explained, adding that this immediately influences his view of the project.
“It’s not our job to teach these people how to do this work. It’s the federal government’s responsibility. That’s what’s encoded in the law, and it’s them dropping the ball and trying to point fingers,” said Yerka.
Consultation does not mean “checking a box and calling that respect for tribal sovereignty,” Carroll said. Still, he warned that BAAJA, by narrowing the scope of projects eligible for THPO consultation and the definition of cultural harm, essentially reduces it to one.
According to the National Congress of American Indians, a 494-page amendment to the bill that purports to protect tribal interests also allows federal authorities to stop a Section 106 review by using their “sole discretion” to determine that a project need not prioritize culturally sacred sites when faced with “other considerations.”
Yerka is concerned about the legislation’s plan to create databases of culturally sensitive locations. Though these databases wouldn’t be publicly accessible, he said there’s precedent for what happens when this information gets into the wrong hands — unhesitant destruction. Dakota Access Pipeline tribal representatives during Standing Rock were pressured to give up the location of a culturally significant site after asking that the pipeline be rerouted to avoid interference. By 4 a.m. the next morning, bulldozers were at the site — and proceeded to destroy it.
He questioned the premise of expediting infrastructure projects, noting that in his experience, delays have resulted from government foot-dragging rather than THPO stagnation.
“We didn’t initiate these projects,” he emphasized.
Yerka proposed an alternate motivation behind the bill — lobbying interests, including critical minerals. His criticism fits how many have described the Roadless Rule rescission and other Trump-era regulation changes, acts, and proposals: prioritizing corporate interests at the expense of the people.
Third-quarter 2026 reports show the top bill lobbyist was commercial airport advocate Airports Council International.
If this is what affordability and jobs look like, Carroll and Yerka want no part of it.
“Our ancestors have already paid a tremendous price for what other people call progress,” said Carroll.
