Archived News

Sylva resolution opposes county’s ‘Sylva Sam’ plans

Protestors walk below the hill where the statue perches during a July 2020 march opposing the monument. Holly Kays photo Protestors walk below the hill where the statue perches during a July 2020 march opposing the monument. Holly Kays photo

Just shy of a year after it passed a resolution demanding the relocation of Sylva’s Confederate statue, the Sylva Town Board has passed a new resolution, this one rebuking the Jackson County Board of Commissioners’ response to its original request. 

The resolution, which passed June 24 by the same 3-2 split that approved the 2020 document, states that the language the county plans to inscribe on new plaques for the statue would “fail to recognize the statue’s historical legacy associated with the Jim Crow South of the early 1900s” and that its prominent presence downtown “implies that the town of Sylva supports the Confederate cause. 

“The statue in its current location will continue to draw controversy and strife and create a threat to public safety within the Town of Sylva limits for residents and visitors,” the resolution reads. “Now, therefore be it resolved that the Sylva Town Board of Commissioners strongly rejects Jackson County’s plan to alter the appearance and meaning of ‘Sylva Sam’ and leave it in its current location.”

After a lengthy public comment session on July 27, 2020, the Sylva board passed its first resolution on the statue , imploring the county commission to move it outside town limits. Depicting an unnamed Confederate solider, the statue was erected in 1915 to honor those who fought in and supported the war effort, and in 1996 it was rededicated as a monument to Jackson County veterans of all wars. It sits midway up the prominent staircase connecting Main Street and the historic courthouse building, overlooking downtown, but it’s located on county property. 

On Aug. 4, commissioners heard nearly two hours of public comment before voting 4-1 to leave the statue where it is but to alter its base to remove the Confederate flag and words “Our Heroes of the Confederacy” emblazoned there. It wasn’t until April 13 — seven months later — that commissioners discussed potential language for the new plaques planned to cover up the original pro-Confederate inscriptions. On May 18, they voted 4-1 to spend $14,000  enacting the plan. 

The Confederate flag will be covered with a large plaque reading, “Jackson County N.C. Civil War Memorial. This monument was erected by citizens of Jackson County in memory of those who died during the American Civil War. Originally dedicated on September 18, 1915. Rededicated on May 11, 1996, to honor Jackson County veterans of all wars.” The words “Our heroes of the Confederacy” would be covered with a plaque spelling out the nation’s unofficial motto, “E Pluribus Unum,” which means “out of many, one.”

Related Items

During Sylva’s June 24 meeting , the three town commissioners who form the board’s majority on this issue roundly condemned the county’s plan. 

“The problem with these monuments is they came up during the Jim Crow era and they attempted to change the whole narrative about what the Confederacy stood for, and Jackson County is just perpetuating that same sentiment,” said Commissioner David Nestler. “This is the Lost Cause. This is rewriting history. This is how you rewrite history — you write ‘E Pluribus Unum’ on a Confederate statue.”

 “We did not ask to destroy the sculpture. We did not ask for the controversy,” said Commissioner Greg McPherson. “But the Town of Sylva should reject discrimination in all of its forms, and this is the most obvious personification of discrimination that I can think of. I think that the language that the county came up with is nonsensical. You have an insurrectionist soldier from a vanquished army now representing all veterans of all wars. It makes absolutely no sense to me.”

Commissioner Ben Guiney, who introduced the resolution, said that he did so out of concern that the statue will continue to be a flashpoint that could end with violence, and out of a desire for his future grandchildren to view him as being on the right side of history. 

“Someone’s going to get hurt. It just doesn’t have to happen,” he said. “The county, they say that it’s a compromise because nobody’s happy about it, and just because nobody’s happy about a decision doesn’t imply it’s a good decision or indeed it was a compromise. The Jackson County Commissioners keep stating that they have to consider the entire county, but the statue’s disproportionately affecting our town more so than the rest of the county.”

However, Commissioners Mary Gelbaugh and Barbara Hamilton disagreed with their fellow board members’ position on the matter, maintaining that many locals whose ancestors died in the war view it as a memorial to their lives rather than as a memorial to the Confederacy itself. 

“We cannot rewrite history,” said Hamilton. “I’m sorry that it happened, but I cannot go against a lot of the locals who have loved ones that served. It was the mothers that had that monument made for sons that were for the Confederacy or the Union.”

“I ask that you individually go to the county as a citizen of the county, since it is a county issue now,” Gelbaugh said to Nestler, Guiney and McPherson. “Resolutions can divide the board. Resolutions can make things awkward and uncomfortable. I support that this is your perception and I support this is how you feel, and I also support how Barbara and I represent a different demographic and how we feel. And I don’t think in any way we are trying to be disrespectful to you or those who feel the way you feel.”

Mayor Lynda Sossamon, who does not vote except in case of a tie, said only, “I look forward to the days when we can all work together and have consensus again instead of issues dividing us.” 

Ultimately, the resolution passed 3-2, with Hamilton and Gelbaugh opposed. The breakdown was the same as the July 2020 vote, which also passed 3-2. 

Leave a comment

7 comments

  • The statue stands prominently in a town that promotes and economically relies on tourism. Few if any visitors could even remotely grasp the nuanced “defense” put forth by those who want the statue to remain where it is. Most see a tribute to division, treason, and slavery. If it is a memorial to the dead, move it to a cemetery.

    posted by Geoffrey Hirsch

    Saturday, 07/03/2021

  • The statue stands prominently in a town that promotes and economically relies on tourism. Few if any visitors could even remotely grasp the nuanced “defense” put forth by those who want the statue to remain where it is. Most see a tribute to division, treason, and slavery. If it is a memorial to the dead, move it to a cemetery.

    posted by Geoffrey Hirsch

    Saturday, 07/03/2021

  • The Civil War was the United States of America vs The Confederate States of America. The Confederate Army killed many United States Soldiers. We don't celebrate other Army's that kill U.S. Soldiers. We don't celebrate other Army's that assassinate U.S. Presidents. Confederate Soldiers are not recognized as US Military Veterans. Confederate Soldiers killed United States Military men that were protecting the Freedoms and Constitution of the United States of America.

    posted by Ulysses S Grant

    Saturday, 07/03/2021

  • Who loved "their negroes"? I love my car. I Own it. The people who support that disgusting statue still think they should OWN "their negroes."

    posted by Leslie

    Thursday, 07/01/2021

  • Who loved "their negroes"? I love my car. I Own it. The people who support that disgusting statue still think they should OWN "their negroes."

    posted by Leslie

    Thursday, 07/01/2021

  • This is just so typical with those who want to flat erase this history! We cannot rewrite it to make our “feelings” appeased…..period. Let history stand as to what it was and how the South was protecting their homeland based on the information they all received at the time. Do we not learn from the history of our relatives?
    The Confederate soldier is a memory for those families who lost their loved ones in that nasty war. It was not a total black and white issue, but was manipulated politically as most everything having to do with politics, and the manner in which the Scallawags and reconstructionists treated the South is unforgivable, yet where is this history and justice?
    It behoves all of us to know all sides of history, whether good or bad, weigh the merits of each side, and learn going forward. Leave the statues where they are, and thanks for some of the commissioners who are taking a sensitive, educated approach. We also cannot appease all who scream and stomp, for if we do we are only creating a world where the noisiest get their way much like spoiled children. Keeping a statue does NOT mean we agree with slavery…..where is this coming from??
    Teach our children the evils of war, the horrid business of slave trading in the North and South, but how America has come full circle and out on top with newer ideals. Our children need to KNOW the truth, so as to not repeat it. They also need to know the side stories of good, caring southerners who loved their negroes and tried to help them always…...there are those too. We don’t need to hide every sad part of our history to appease a few…..period!

    posted by Sonja Thompson

    Monday, 06/28/2021

  • If my ancestors died trying to preserve the institution of slavery, I would feel embarrassed. I can only assume that those who want to remember a gr. gr. gr. grandparent they never met who did horrible things are, themselves, at least racist enough not to care.

    Get your stupid statue the f out of Sylva.

    posted by JB

    Thursday, 06/24/2021

Smokey Mountain News Logo
SUPPORT THE SMOKY MOUNTAIN NEWS AND
INDEPENDENT, AWARD-WINNING JOURNALISM
Go to top
Payment Information

/

At our inception 20 years ago, we chose to be different. Unlike other news organizations, we made the decision to provide in-depth, regional reporting free to anyone who wanted access to it. We don’t plan to change that model. Support from our readers will help us maintain and strengthen the editorial independence that is crucial to our mission to help make Western North Carolina a better place to call home. If you are able, please support The Smoky Mountain News.

The Smoky Mountain News is a wholly private corporation. Reader contributions support the journalistic mission of SMN to remain independent. Your support of SMN does not constitute a charitable donation. If you have a question about contributing to SMN, please contact us.